Recipe for Success – Tips for a Successful Recipe Search

Recipe:  A series of step-by-step instructions for preparing ingredients you forgot to buy, in utensils you don’t own, to make a dish the dog wouldn’t eat.

~Author Unknown

I recently read a New York Times article about recipe search engines.  The article specifically mentions the new Google recipe search and the Bing recipe search functions.  It also mentions specific recipe search sites Foodily and Cookzillas.

The title of the article is “Can Recipe Search Engines Make You a Better Cook?”That’s a bit misleading. It is really about the quality of the recipes you can find using these sites.  The article didn’t give great marks to any of these search engines.  They all had flaws such as wrong or misleading nutrition information, cooking times or ingredient lists.  The article implies that some food sites intentionally post incorrect information so that their recipes rank higher in the search engine results.

Google Recipe Search:

Picture of Google Recipe Search

Click to Enlarge

Google’s recipe search function allows to specify what ingredients you want or don’t want to use.  You can also specify cooking time and calories.

One thing I don’t like is that here in Canada, the Google recipe search doesn’t appear by default.

 

 

 

 

 

Bing Recipe Search:

Picture of Bing Recipe Search

Click to Enlarge

If you haven’t heard of Bing, it is Microsoft’s search engine.  Initially, I had a lot of trouble even finding the recipe search function.  It turns out that if you perform a search with the word recipe, you may have the option to select the recipe search tab.  I say may because Bing won’t always show the recipe tab.  Try searching for Half Hour Pudding, and then try searching for Cheese cake.  You’ll see what I mean.

 

 

Foodily:

I had never heard of this site before I read the article.  The premise is interesting in that it integrates with Facebook so that you can refine your search results based on recipes that your friends like.

Picture of Foodily

Click to Enlarge

Cookzillas:

Picture of Cookzillas

Click to Enlarge

It looks like this site is actually using Google’s search engine.  It also shows Google ads. The  big difference here is that the thumbnail pictures of the recipes are quite big.  I like this because I like to see pictures of the end result when I’m looking for a recipe.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Conclusions:

I’ve tried all of the mentioned sites, and I don’t think they are really that bad.  Like any search (especially with Google these days), you do need to filter out the noise.  I also think that anyone who has a food blog should consider formatting their recipe posts so they get indexed by these search engines.    I’m currently in the process of doing this my self, and I’m planning a post with all of the details.

Normally though, I have a long list of Food blogs that I follow.  Since I’ve subscribed to the RSS feed for these blogs, I can search them all at once using Google Reader.

From time to time I will also search sites like Foodbuzz.  This is a great way to find new blogs to follow.

Of course, I do enjoy flipping through magazines and real cookbooks when I’m trying to decide what to cook.

Now, please tell me how you search for new and interesting recipes.  Do you used any of these search engines?  Do you think they are a good idea?

Posted in Cooking
3 comments on “Recipe for Success – Tips for a Successful Recipe Search
  1. Cheryl Moore says:

    I have never used any of the search engines you mentioned. I usually look through magazines and cookbooks when I’m looking for recipes. If I need a specific recipe I will look at individual websites that have been recommended to me or that I have found helpful for other recipes. I will definitely try some of the search engines.

    • Mark says:

      Do you search the websites one at a time? I find searching via my Google RSS Reader to be really useful.

  2. Janet Stewart says:

    I have tried searching the web for recipes. I usually just use google and put in the name of the recipe or ingredient I want to find. The other day I bought some kale but did not know how to cook it. I was not after anything specific just how to cook. Google came up with pages of kale recipes. Or else I look through magazines or ask my son or daughter how they would cook things. Works good

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Get a monthly email with all the latest news from Food Construed.

When you sign up, you can download a free copy of my ebook, "Storing Fresh Fruit and Vegetables"